The George Massey tunnel is considered B.C.’s worst traffic congestion point, and unable to withstand a major earthquake. (Black Press Media file)

Bridge or tunnel: Metro Vancouver to decide on Massey crossing recommendation

Task force will send recommendation to province

Metro Vancouver residents could learn what a likely Massey tunnel replacement option will look like early Wednesday afternoon.

The George Massey Crossing Task Force will receive a report about six short-listed replacement options for the aging tunnel. The task force was started after the NDP scrapped the previous Liberal government’s 10-lane bridge proposal.

The report highlights the advantages and disadvantages of the six options:

  • New eight-lane immersed-tube tunnel with multi-use pathway
  • New six-lane immersed-tube tunnel plus use of the existing tunnel to provide two dedicated lanes for transit.
  • New eight-lane bridge with multi-use pathway.
  • New eight-lane deep-bored tunnel plus use of the existing tunnel for a multi-use pathway.
  • New six-lane bridge plus use of the existing tunnel to provide two dedicated lanes for transit.
  • New six-lane deep-bored tunnel plus use of the existing tunnel to provide two dedicated lanes for transit.

It notes the deep-bored tunnel options are “technically challenging and are assessed as high risk.” This option would risk sink holes appearing and require “removal of three million cubic meters of salt-contaminated soil during construction.” The cost is estimated at three times the cost of the immersed-tube tunnel and bridge options. The report points to the Alaskan Way Viaduct replacement tunnel project in Seattle, which finished late and overbudget after a boring machine, dubbed Berta, got stuck multiple times. The machine needed for the Massey project would be 20 metres wide, compared to 17.5 metres for the Seattle project.

The immersed-tube tunnel options are described as “moderately challenging,” with the most complex environmental assessment due to in-river and riverbank work. This option would require one kilometre of tunnel, a large staging area and removal of 1.5 million cubic meters of salt-contaminated soil. It’s estimated to cost the same as a bridge option, although costs are not yet known. The 10-lane bridge option was estimated to cost $3.5 billion.

The bridge options would require the least complex environmental assessment, the report notes, as it would be similar to the one already done for the 10-lane option. It would require around three kilometres of bridge and approaches, with abutments on land and foundations of at least 80 metres in depth.

The current tunnel, although expected to remain “serviceable” for 50 years, does not meet seismic requirements, the report said.

The task force is expected to come to a decision that will serve as its recommendation to Metro Vancouver mayors Wednesday afternoon, although it will not be binding.

READ MORE: Council wants Massey crossing project to include South Surrey interchanges

READ MORE: Unity needed among mayors on Massey Tunnel replacement, Delta mayor says


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

5 to 10 cm of snow still coming to Fraser Valley: Environment Canada

Hard to say when the freezing rain will turn to regular rainfall, Environment Canada says

Slideshow: Hope’s winter weather in photos

Readers submit photos of Hope under a blanket of snow

RCMP looking for tips in rash of crime in Hope

Theives broke into homes and cars in the Kawkawa Lake area

Fraser Cascade superintendent announces retirement

Dr. Karen Nelson has worked for School District 78 for 29 years

FVRD seeking outdoor rec feedback

Open house meetings slated for next week

UBC, Iranian-Canadian community create memorial scholarship in honour of victims

The Jan. 8 crash killed 176 people, including 57 Canadians

Disrespectful that Horgan won’t meet during northern B.C. tour: hereditary chief

Na’moks said he was frustrated Horgan didn’t meet with the chiefs

Update: Highway reopens after crash west of Revelstoke

Drive BC also reported a vehicle incident 10 km east of Golden.

Vancouver police investigate after man found dead in vehicle

Man has not been identified and no one has been arrested

Canucks extend home win streak to 8 with 4-1 triumph over Sharks

Victory lifts Vancouver into top spot in NHL’s Pacific Division

BC Green Party leader visits northern B.C. pipeline protest site

Adam Olsen calls for better relationship between Canada, British Columbia and First Nations

Most Read