Human Rights Tribunal denies church’s request to toss out White Rock Pride Society’s complaint

Star of the Sea and White Rock Pride Society to go to Human Rights Tribunal hearing

An application made by the Star of the Sea Parish of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Vancouver to dismiss a human rights complaint filed against them by the White Rock Pride Society has been denied.

The complaint is to progress to a Human Rights Tribunal hearing, however, a date for the hearing has not yet been published.

White Rock Pride Society filed a complaint against the church last June, alleging discrimination by the Star of the Sea Parish on the basis of sexual orientation.

RELATED: White Rock Pride Society files human rights complaint against Star of the Sea Church

Earlier that year, Pride Society president Ernie Klassen told Peace Arch News that his organization felt discriminated against because Star of the Sea would not rent its community centre to the society for an upcoming “Love is Love” pride event.

Archbishop delegate James Borkowski told PAN last year the decision to deny the event application was made because the event would be contrary to the teachings on faith and morals of the Catholic church.

The Tribunal published a 28-page document May 26 outlining the decision to deny the Parish’s application.

Tribunal member Kathleen Smith details a number of reasons why the complaint should move to a hearing, including that she was not persuaded by Star of the Sea that the Pride Society has no reasonable prospect for success in its human rights complaint.

In the application to dismiss the complaint, the Parish asked the Tribunal to apply protections of the Human Rights Code in a way that proportionately balances the religious freedoms of the Parish with the rights of the Society members to be free from discrimination based on sexual orientation.

“In the Parish’s view, requiring it to facilitate and tacitly support and encourage an event directly contrary to their religious teachings and beliefs on sexual morality, would amount to a disproportionate interference in the religious freedoms of the Parish,” Smith wrote.

RELATED: White Rock Catholic church stands firm on decision to deny gay pride event

The Pride Society argues that the Parish did not make inquiries regarding the Pride Society’s mandate, what activities were planned for the event (and whether the Society had any flexibility in this respect) and who might be attending the event.

“The Society points to evidence that the Catholic Church does not condemn homosexuals, only the homosexual act. It says the Parish did not make any effort to communicate with representatives of the Society to resolve whether its concerns with the proposed fundraiser event… could be addressed by the society.”

Smith wrote that the Parish made a “compelling argument” about the need to protect religious spaces.

“This case is complicated, however, by the fact that the Parish makes a part of its space available to those outside of its Catholic community,” Smith wrote. “I agree with the Society that a determination about reasonable accommodation short of undue hardship requires the careful examination (of) complex and nuanced issues, including the meaning of Pride, as well as the competing rights of the parties in this case. In my view, these issues cannot be determined on this application and require a full hearing.”

LGBTQReligion

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

First rainstorm of the season pelting the Lower Mainland

Batten down the hatches as heavy rains, wind, and some localized flooding possible

Irish folk supergroup Kíla set to perform on Saturday

Online concert will be available through Harrison Festival Society

Reported Kelowna Hells Angels member dies in Fraser Valley motorcycle crash

Michael “Speedy” Christiansen was found dead on Monday morning near Ruby Creek on Highway 7

Council to take a second look at developer’s plans for gravel pit in Silver Creek

Emil Anderson want their Hockin Road property to be a gravel pit, eventually a subdivision

Fundraiser golf tournament raises $74,000 for Fraser Valley hospitals

Chilliwack General Hospital will benefit from a tourney at held at the Sandpiper Golf Resort

B.C. reports 96 new COVID-19 cases, one hospital outbreak

61 people in hospital as summer ends with election

Refresh of Liberal government’s agenda comes amid new looming COVID-19 crisis

Lockdowns saw fed spending soar to historic levels in effort to offset pandemic’s blow to Canadians’ livelihoods

‘Unprecedented’ coalition demands end to B.C. salmon farms

First Nations, commercial fishermen among group calling for action on Cohen recommendations

Earthquake off coast of Washington recorded at 4.1 magnitude

The quake was recorded at a depth of 10 kilometres

B.C.’s top doctor says she’s received abuse, death threats during COVID-19 response

Henry has become a national figure during her time leading B.C.’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic

Join Black Press Media and Do Some Good

Pay it Forward program supports local businesses in their community giving

BC Liberals must change gears from election cynicism, focus on the issues: UBC professors

COVID-19 response and recovery is likely to dominate platforms

B.C. could be without a new leader for multiple weeks after Election Day: officials

More than 20K mail-in voting packages were requested within a day of B.C. election being called

Dozens of Canadian venues to light up red in support of entertainment workers

Local facilities among dozens across Canada to participate in Light Up Live

Most Read