Skip to content

Horgan urges federal government to carry half the health-care load as premiers meet

Premier: ‘We need to reimagine public health care in Canada’
Premier John Horgan gestures during a break from a meeting of Canada’s premiers at the Songhees Wellness Centre in Victoria, B.C., on Monday, July 11, 2022 THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito

Canada’s provinces and territories need a partner that will share half the financial load on the health-care system, which is buckling without stable, predictable and long-term funding, British Columbia Premier John Horgan said Monday.

The country’s 13 premiers began two days of meetings in Victoria with the primary topic of health-care funding as Canada eases out of the COVID-19 pandemic with a severe shortage of doctors, nurses and other health workers.

“We need to reimagine public health care in Canada,” said Horgan, who chairs the premiers’ Council of the Federation.

He said the premiers already sent the federal government a detailed funding proposal and they are waiting for a response.

Horgan received a text from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Monday saying Ottawa is aware of the funding situation and “they’ve been working on it,” he said.

“But we can’t determine what we’re going to do with money we don’t have,” he said.

“And we can go a lot further if we had a partner that was carrying half the load.”

Horgan told a news conference that the history of health-care funding in Canada was one of “dual responsibility” before cuts began in the 1990s.

“That has diminished over decades. This is not at the feet of the current Trudeau administration,” he added.

Successive federal governments have provided one-time funding to address immediate health-care needs, and that approach isn’t working, Horgan said, adding stable funding is needed.

“Once those temporary, part-time, once-only funding pots empty, we have a void, which then is inevitably filled by the jurisdictions that are providing the services,” Horgan said of the provinces and territories.

The premiers have called on Ottawa to increase health funding to 35 per cent, from what they have said currently amounts to 22 per cent.

Stable funding would allow provinces and territories to invest in a human resource strategy, so they aren’t “poaching” from each other as they train the next generation of health-care workers to take the burden off those who were celebrated in the early days of the pandemic, Horgan said.

“It’s just not good enough to show our gratitude. We need to now show we’re committed to those workers, those patients, and that’s what these discussions are about this afternoon and into tomorrow,” he said.

Canadian nursing leaders also met with premiers earlier Monday with a message that nurses are suffering through a “dire staffing crisis” that threatens the sustainability of public health care.

Referencing that meeting, Horgan said people working in the health-care system are “strained beyond belief.”

A statement from Linda Silas, president of the Canadian Federation of Nurses Unions, said the system is “on the brink of disaster.”

Silas said nurses have been “struggling through extreme staffing shortages, forced overtime and cancelled vacations, with no end in sight” to untenable conditions.

The federation said its proposals focus on retaining nurses, encouraging them to return to the profession and adding measures to recruit and train more of them.

Silas said provincial commitments to strengthen health care are welcome, but “no one province or territory can solve this on their own,” and federal funding will be key.

Premiers also met with leaders of the National Indigenous Organizations, made up of the Assembly of First Nations, Congress of Aboriginal Peoples, Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, Métis National Council and the Native Women’s Association of Canada.

Horgan said they discussed issues including land claims, reconciliation, child welfare, missing and murdered Indigenous women and the “archaic” Indian Act, saying it was introduced when residential school policies were being implemented.

He said they also talked about the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, which the B.C. government is in the process of implementing. Ottawa has also pledged to implement the declaration, and Assembly of First Nations B.C. Regional Chief Terry Teegee called for a first ministers meeting within the next year to focus on how to adopt it across all levels of Canadian governments.

Horgan was also asked about how the premiers plan to manage rising inflation and said they will be discussing “best practices” from their jurisdictions to help reduce costs for the public and protect them from “seismic issues” affecting the global economy, including the pandemic and Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine.

—Brenna Owen, The Canadian Press

RELATED: B.C. First Nations, premier urge other provinces to adopt UN rights declaration

RELATED: Public health-care system on ‘brink of disaster,’ Canadian nurses federation says